Running the room

What to do about the person who dominates the room

Almost every room has one. The director who speaks first on every item, the relative who takes over every family dinner, the group member who has advice on every topic and turns each one back to their own experience. Usually they mean well. They are often successful and confident, and used to running the room in the rest of their life. Left alone, they teach everyone else to stop talking.

The leader's job is to make room for everyone else while keeping that person engaged.

Notice the cost early

The cost of a dominant voice is rarely visible in what they say. It shows up in what other people stop saying. Watch for people who used to ask questions and now do not, for discussions that end as soon as one person gives an opinion, and for quiet people who start missing meetings or skipping the family gathering. By the time someone complains, the pattern has usually been in place for months.

Use structure before you use a conversation

Most of the problem can be handled with the format, because the format applies to everyone. Go around the room so each person speaks once before anyone speaks twice. On a board, ask for each director's view before open discussion, and ask the most senior voice to go last. Hold a questions-only period before anyone gives advice. Ask quieter people a specific question by name. At a dinner table, use one shared question so every person gets a turn.

Give the dominant person a role: timekeeper, the one who summarizes what they heard, or the one who asks the last question. It gives their energy somewhere useful to go.

Nobody feels singled out when the structure does the work, and the room gets better for everyone at once.

Have the private conversation

If the structure is not enough, talk to the person privately and soon. Do it in person or by phone, not by email. Start with what they bring, because it is usually real. Then describe what you have seen, specifically and without labels: at the last two meetings you spoke first on every topic, and two people who usually contribute did not speak at all. Ask what they think is going on. Most people respond well to being treated as a partner in making the room work.

Ask for their help rather than asking them to stop: I need you to help me draw out the quieter people. Your questions are good. Ask fewer of them, and ask them later.

In a family, the same conversation works with a parent or a sibling. It is harder to start, and it matters more.

Follow through

Notice and acknowledge the change when it happens. If it does not happen, have a second conversation that is clearer about the effect on the room. The worst outcome is a leader who sees the problem and waits. Everyone else is watching to see whether the leader will protect the room, and they will decide for themselves whether it is worth their time.

Before your next gathering

  • Who in your room has stopped asking questions?
  • Does each person speak once before anyone speaks twice?
  • Do you hold a questions-only period before advice or opinions?
  • Have you given your most active voice a role?
  • If the pattern continues, when will you have the private conversation?
  • What specific behavior will you describe, without labels?

From Leading the Room, a book in progress by Gerry Morton on how to lead any room where people gather, drawn from twenty-two years in peer groups across Vistage, EO, YPO and TIGER 21 and on boards.

The Room Letter

One practice a month for anyone who leads a room. Subscribe and get the one-page Meeting Checklist.

Monthly. Unsubscribe in one click. Privacy